Life-Sustaining Treatment Preferences: Matches And Mismatches Between Patients’ Preferences And Clinicians’ Perceptions
Posted on Tuesday, August 13th, 2013 at 10:05 am by lifemediamatters
Authors: Lois Downey, David Au, J. Randall Curtis and Ruth A. Engelberg
Journal of Pain and Symptom Management, July 2013
Clinicians erred about patients’ wishes when patients did not want treatment
End of life discussions have the potential for reducing unwanted treatment, decreasing health care costs and improving quality of end of life care. Although many patients prefer end of life care focused on comfort rather than prolongation of life, a substantial minority prefer life-sustaining therapy regardless of the outcome. It is important that clinicians understand each patient’s preferences for end of life care.
A paired group of 196 patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and their 68 primary care physicians at two Veterans Affairs facilities in Washington state were evaluated. Each patient was asked to complete a survey including the following question regarding mechanical ventilation:
‘‘If you were in your current health and unable to breathe on your own, would you want to be on a breathing machine for a few days? There would be no guarantee that you would be able to come off the breathing machine and be able to breathe on your own.’’
The parallel clinician item question was:
‘‘In his current health, do you think [this patient] would want hospitalization in an ICU with shortterm mechanical ventilation with an uncertain chance of being extubated alive?’ ’
Regarding cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), the patient question was:
‘‘CPR would consist of electric shocks to the heart, pumping on the chest, help with breathing and heart medications given through the veins. Possible side effects of CPR include broken ribs and memory loss. In your current health, would you want CPR if your heart were to stop beating?’’
The clinician question was:
‘‘In his current health, do you think [this patient] would want CPR if he were to have a cardiac arrest?’’
Almost 85 percent of patients reported never having had a discussion about end of life treatment issues with their clinician, while more that 70 percent of the clinicians believed that they probably/definitely knew the patients’ general lifesustaining treatment preferences.
Paired patientclinician responses revealed many clinician errors in perception, with 39 percent in error about patients’ preferences regarding mechanical ventilation. Regarding preferences for CPR, 25 percent were in error. When errors were made, clinicians were more likely to believe their patients wanted lifesustaining treatment, while the patient reported that they did not.
Patients in this study were significantly more accepting of CPR than of mechanical ventilation. Other studies have shown that the chances of surviving CPR is considerably lower than survival after mechanical ventilation for an acute exacerbation of COPD. Furthermore, patients’ own estimates of their chances of surviving CPR are considerably higher than their clinicians’ estimates.
These results demonstrate that end of life discussions need to occur more frequently, recur over the course of the clinicianpatient relationship, include a focus on goals and consider preferences for specific treatments.
Life Matters Media featured in the Good Men Project
Posted on Monday, December 10th, 2012 at 8:06 pm by Life Matters Media
Dr. Judi Strauss-Lipkin, 69, is the owner and principal of Strauss Financial in Chicago, Ill., and former professor of human resource management at Benedictine University. She spoke to Life Matters Media about her experiences caring for her aging husband. Larry, 87, a retired accountant and WWII veteran, is her husband of 26 years. Larry has suffered bouts with heart failure, Bell’s palsy, COPD and short-term memory loss.
Read the interview at the Good Men Project.
Learn more from the Life Matters Media Newswire:
- Advance Care Planning
- Facing the Darkness
- Health Care
- Health Care
- Hospice and Palliative Care
- In The News
- Life Choices
- Managing Our Mortality
- Politics and Law
- Relationships and Intimacy
- Social Outreach
- Society and Culture
- The Conversation
- Treatments and Illness
- Treatments and Illness
- Zion-Benton News
- When Parents Disagree With The Doctors
- Illinois Prepares For Medical Marijuana
- Jesus Wept. Why?
- Indiana Hunter’s Decision To Stop Life-Sustaining Treatments Spurs Discussion
- Taxes– And The Costs Of Long Term Care
- December 2013
- November 2013
- October 2013
- September 2013
- August 2013
- July 2013
- June 2013
- May 2013
- April 2013
- March 2013
- February 2013
- January 2013
- December 2012
- November 2012
- October 2012
- September 2012
- August 2012
Daniel Gaitan serves as a content producer...More